Ryan
Santana
Ms.
Matyakubova
English
110, Section F
16
November 2013
Annotated
Bibliography
Thesis:
The U.S. government lowering the drinking age in the country is
a logical step to make in this day and age.
Daniloff, Caleb. "Drinking: 18 vs.
21." BU Today. Boston University, 21 Oct. 2010. Web. 10 Nov. 2013.
This
article discusses the consumption of alcohol on college campuses. The author
begins with the topic of being able to go to war, but not being legal to drink
alcohol. Daniloff references back to the Prohibition days and the Vietnam War.
The author gives background information on the way the legal drinking age
became twenty-one. He discusses some organization that work to bring the
drinking age down to eighteen and how they plan to do so. The author then
quotes the responses of Seaman and William DeJong, experts on the subject, to
questions regarding the legal drinking age.
A
big concept in this article, which supports my thesis, is if it were legal to
drink at eighteen, less people would feel the urge to do it. Daniloff tells us
that when he went to college, while the drinking age was eighteen, students
didn’t feel a need to drink alcohol because it was legal. American students
living in Montreal, where the drinking age is eighteen, don’t find the idea of
drinking alcohol to be that intriguing. They don’t find as much pleasure in
doing it as college students in America do. I will use this to show that if the
drinking age were lowered, most college students will be less interested in
drinking.
Engs, Ruth C. "Why Drinking Age
Should Be Lowered: Dr. Ruth Engs." Why Drinking Age Should Be Lowered: Dr. Ruth Engs.
Ruth C. Engs, n.d. Web. 11 Nov. 2013.
An
expert professor who has done research and feels that the drinking should be
lowered to eighteen or nineteen writes this article to express his opinion.
Ruth C. Engs says that young adults should be allowed to drink in controlled
environments. He says that the youth drinks for the thrill of doing something
illegal and that making the drinking age twenty-one is not working now. College
students lack responsible drinking behavior because of the drinking age.
Drinking responsibly is learned in other cultures where the drinking age is
eighteen. We need to change the law because it is counterproductive.
I
plan to use this article because of the statistics displayed by Engs, which
prove that those who begin drinking under the age of 21 are more likely to
become heavy drinkers and end up binge drinking. He supports my thesis when
saying that young adults should be allowed to order drinks in safe, orderly
settings such as restaurants, bars, and clubs, and school events. In these situations,
responsible drinking can be instilled. He also points out that one of the
reasons young adults drink is because they find
pleasure in breaking laws and getting away with it. Binge drinking
amongst young adults is partly caused by the drinking age being twenty-one.
Hanson, David J. "Effective
Alcohol Education: What Works with Underage Youths." Alcohol: Problems and Solutions. David J. Hanson,
n.d. Web. 10 Nov. 2013.
David
Hanson writes this article to inform the readers on how the U.S.’s policy for
complete alcohol abstinence by those who are under twenty-one is unsuccessful.
Alcohol education only provides abstinence-only lessons, and not enough
responsible drinking lessons. Educators exaggerate the effects of alcohol in
order to scare students away from consuming. Alcohol is not the problem; the
abuse of alcohol is what causes an issue. We need to teach the youth on how to
drink in moderation, and not just hope they never have a sip of beer to begin
with.
Hanson
explains how health educators have only exaggerated the dangers of alcohol in
the hopes of “scaring” students away from experimenting with liquor. This has
proved to be ineffective and counterproductive. Most
schools try and convince students that alcohol is a gateway drug, and to never
try it. Statements like these cause young, curios teens to test the effects of
alcohol, resulting in binge drinking. If the drinking age were lowered, more
health education classes would focus on responsible drinking instead of
abstinence. More new drinkers will be able to practice realizing their limits
before it becomes hazardous.
Stromberg, Drew. "Lowering the
Drinking Age." Students for Sensible Drug Policy. Students for Sensible Drug Policy, n.d. Web. 09 Nov. 2013.
Even
though the drinking age is twenty-one, most teens have had a drink of alcohol
or claim that it is easy to obtain. The federal government has the overall
legal drinking age, but each state should be able to have their own policies,
which help reduce the harm in the usage of alcohol. The current drinking age
forces the youth to experiment with alcohol in unsafe environments, leading to
binge drinking. Schools also only provide abstinence-only education instead of
encouraging responsible drinking to avoid alcohol abuse. Because of the
drinking age, young adults have limited places of where they can hang out with
their older friends.
In
my paper, I plan to emphasize his point on the youth testing the limits of
alcohol in risky environments. Young teenagers tend
to become curious to experience the effects alcohol does to the body and mind.
This causes teens to try drinking liquor in places with little or no
supervision. If the drinking age were lowered, it would not force such young
people to test the outcomes of drinking alcohol in places where there is no
responsible adult observing them. Experimenting with alcohol can lead to a
higher level of binge drinking. I will again emphasize school’s lack of
responsible drinking education and how abstinence-only education is
counterproductive.
No comments:
Post a Comment