Ryan
Santana
Ms.
Matyakubova
English
110, Section F
11 December
2013
Research
Paper
A More Sensible Approach
According to the National
Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism (NIH), American’s ages eighteen and
over that have had at least one drink in the past year include: 59.6% amongst
women and 71.8% amongst men. Even though the legal drinking age is twenty-one,
some states in the U.S. have exceptions when it comes to the consumption of
alcohol. The U.S. government lowering the drinking age in the country is a
logical step to make in this day and age. Citizens support lowering the
drinking age because it is a rational modification to the law that needs to be
made.
Drew Stromberg states in his article “Lowering
the Drinking Age” that the current minimum drinking age forces young people to
experiment with alcohol in risky environments. Young teenagers tend to become
curious to experience the effects alcohol does to the body and mind. This
causes teens to try drinking liquor in places with little or no supervision.
Since the drinking age is twenty-one, this is common amongst teens as young as
fourteen. Teen’s testing the limits of liquor in such risky atmospheres can
pose a danger to the tester’s life. John McCardell, president of Middlebury
College, talks about the drinking age when he states, "It hasn't reduced or
eliminated drinking. It has simply driven it underground, behind closed doors,
into the most risky and least manageable of settings". McCardell says the law has created a dangerous culture of
irresponsible and reckless behavior, unsupervised binge and extreme drinking,
and forces kids to try and perfect the art of getting drunk as fast as possible
by playing drinking games. If the drinking age were lowered, it would not force such young
people to test the outcomes of drinking alcohol in places where there is no
responsible adult observing them. How does this pose a threat?
Because of lack of
supervision, experimenting with alcohol leads to a higher level of binge
drinking among youth (Stromberg). Since the drinking age is so high, it forces
young teens to test how much their body can handle before shutting down. This
is attempted behind closed doors, which contributes to teens overdrinking. A
new drinker can have problems determining their body’s limit, which can result
in alcohol poisoning. Teens tend to binge drink because they envy twenty-one
year old adults, being that that age seems so far away. Eighteen may be right
around the corner, but being able to legally drink alcohol is not one of the
availabilities when turning eighteen. Some experts like McCardell believe that
the drinking age has caused an increase in extreme drinking. He argues that
lowering the drinking age will make kids safer.
CBS news interviewed two
parents whose son has been a victim of alcohol poisoning due to underage
drinking. Gordie
Bailey was a freshman at the University of Colorado. He began to undergo a Chi
Psi fraternity initiation in which he had to go through a hazing process. In
this hazing process, him and twenty-six other pledges were forced to drink ten
gallons of hard liquor and wine in half an hour. Gordie’s stepfather states he
had around 15-20 shots, but drinking it straight from the bottle. By the end of
his extreme drinking, Gordie’s eyes were rolled to the back of his head and he
could not walk. He was in alcoholic trauma. The fraternity brothers left him
passed out on the couch for nine hours until they finally called 911. Gordie
died of alcohol poisoning. His parents believe it was very preventable and
inexcusable. They believe that if the drinking age was eighteen, their son’s
death could have been avoided. It was illegal for the fraternity brothers to
drink, have alcohol in their house, and serve drinks to minors. The parents of
Gordie believe that this is what delayed the 911 call, which resulted in the
situation being pushed to the limits of death. The fraternity brothers not
calling 911 soon enough further proves this statement by Wade Shields: “According to
the NIAAA, more than 5,000 minors die of alcohol-related causes every year.
Many of these deaths are preventable, but underage drinkers often do not call
for help because they are worried about marring their permanent record with
charges related to underage drinking”. Mark Beckner, the chief of
police in Boulder, Colorado, was on the scene during this tragedy and this case
is one of the reasons he is a supporter of lowering the drinking age.
McCardell also supports the
story of Gordie Bailey as reasoning for lowering the drinking age. He believes
eighteen is the age of adulthood for firing weapons and “putting your life on
the line in battle”. The legal age to enroll in the army is eighteen. In the
army, one is instructed on how to use weapons and is expected to fight for our
country. Soldiers under the age of twenty-one are likely to kill someone in
war, but cannot legally have a drink in the United States. The idea of being
legal to take someone’s life, but not being able to loosen up and wine down
with a beer or glass of liquor is unreasonable. The government has its
priorities backwards when it comes to this issue. A citizen can risk their life
in war but cannot come home and have a drink of alcohol. Which one is more
dangerous, killing a person or having a drink? Our nation’s leaders would
rather train an eighteen year old how to kill, but wont allow them to have a
beer. Many major decisions are available to eighteen year olds, the consumption
of alcohol not being one of them.
At eighteen, one is able to
vote for the men and women who will run the country. This essential decision
affects your life, as well as the nations state of being. The government
believes that at eighteen or minds are capable of making the rational
decisions. They trust and urge us to participate in the process of deciding who
the leaders of America should be. The government wants the young generation to
contribute, and have a say-so in major changes throughout the nation. This demonstrates
that the government is aware of eighteen year olds having logical methods of
thinking. If they did not, the age to vote would be twenty-one. If us eighteen
year olds are mature enough to vote on a nation wide decision, then why is it
not legal for us to purchase alcoholic beverages? With the help of health
education, our minds should be able to handle the responsibility of drinking
alcohol.
Stromberg also claims in
his article that school’s involvement in drug safety solely provides
“abstinence-only” education instead of encouraging responsibility while
drinking. Doctor David J. Hanson states, “Exaggerating the dangers of alcohol consumption has been part of
alcohol education for over one hundred years. Scare tactics and “health
terrorism” are not only ineffective but also counterproductive. As young people
mature… alcohol educators have lost all credibility”. Most schools try and
convince students that alcohol is a gateway drug, and to never try it.
Statements like these cause young, curios teens to test the effects of alcohol,
resulting in binge drinking. John McCardell believes that abstinence from drinking is
impractical.
McCardell states,
“Alcohol education is what we need and that is a very important part of our
proposal. And by that I don't mean temperance lectures and I don't mean
prohibition, nor do I mean encouragement to drink”. By this statement, he
means mandatory classes in high school that discuss the chemistry of alcohol,
consequences of abuse, and sitting in on Alcohol Anonymous sessions. If the
drinking age were lowered, more health education classes would focus on
responsible drinking instead of abstinence. More new drinkers will be able to
practice realizing their limits before it becomes hazardous.
CBS News
reports that the drinking age forces student to
pre-load, or down as much of the “forbidden fruit” as possible before going out
in order to avoid getting caught drinking in public. Professor Ruth C.
Engs states that those who begin drinking under the age of 21 are more likely
to become heavy drinkers and end up binge drinking. For example, 22% of all
students under 21 are heavy drinkers while 18% of students over 21 years of age
are heavy drinkers. Among student drinkers only, 32% of under age compared to
24% of legal age are heavy drinkers. If it were
legal to drink over the age of eighteen, would there be such an urge to drink
alcohol at a young age? Caleb Daniloff states in his article, “But back
in the ’60s, when the drinking age in New York, where I went to school, was 18,
we didn’t feel a need to do that stuff because it was legal.” Daniloff further
talks about American students living in Montreal where the drinking age is
eighteen. The students behaved surprisingly civil when it came to alcohol, like
it wasn’t a “big deal”. This shows that
if the drinking age were lowered in the United States, there would be less of
an urge to drink amongst the youth.
Expert
opinions, like that of Engs, agree that the drinking age should be lowered to
eighteen based on research. Engs has been researching for over twenty years the
issue of college age youth drinking. He believes that young adults should be
allowed to order drinks in safe, orderly settings such as restaurants, bars,
and clubs, and school events. Engs states, “In these situations responsible
drinking could be taught through role modeling and educational programs. Mature
and sensible drinking behavior would be expected”. With this research and
expert opinion, if the conditions permit then us young adults, eighteen and up,
should be allowed to have a drink of alcohol.
Another
contribution to the reason teens tend to overdrink, disregarding their limits,
is because most college students 17-20 years old
find a thrill in drinking. Shield states, “More
than 70 percent of teens drink by the time they reach 18, and 80 percent of
college students drink, according to the National Institute on Alcohol Abuse
and Alcoholism.” Because of the way it makes
them feel and the fact that’s its illegal, they find it fun. To the younger
generation, and maybe even the older generation, being intoxicated is a way to
step out of one’s comfort zone. Drinking alcohol is a way to be rebellious and
defiant. The younger generation finds pleasure in breaking laws and getting
away with it. Engs claims, “Although the legal purchase age is 21 years
of age, a majority of college students under this age consume alcohol but in an
irresponsible manner. This is because drinking by these youth is seen as an
enticing "forbidden fruit," a "badge of rebellion against authority"
and a symbol of "adulthood". Binge drinking amongst young adults is
partly caused by the drinking age being twenty-one.
Another
reason lowering the drinking age is the most rational step to make is because
the law is simply not productive. Though it is illegal, under aged drinkers
will always find a way to get a bottle of liquor or case of beer. Even police
officers can only do so much in controlling the consumption of alcohol from
underage drinkers. Beckner says to CBS News,
"We're not in a situation where we can stop it. The best we can do is try
to contain it." He further states that as much as the police department
enforces the law, it is not being effective. The area’s in which the police
force should focus their efforts on is the drinking and driving lawbreakers,
not young adults having a beer (Beckner). Regardless of police efforts, under
aged drinkers will always find a way to obtain alcohol illegally or not. As
Shield says in his article, “It’s time the
arbitrary drinking age of 21 was lowered to 18, because there is no evidence
that the National Minimum Drinking Age Act is effective or protects the people
it is intended to protect.”
Citizens against lowering the drinking age have multiple reasons
as to why they believe the drinking age should stay at twenty-one. Amongst
these reasons, people who support the current drinking age claim there would be
an increase in vehicle fatalities due to young, drunk drivers. Alex Johnson, reporter of the NCS News,
states in his article that organizations like the National Transportation Safety
Board and the Mothers Against Drunk Driving support the current drinking age
because of studies by the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, which
estimate from 1975 (around the time the drinking age was raised to twenty-one)
to 2003, 22,798 lives were saved due to the passing of the law. The NHTSA did
not explain how they concluded this estimate and furthermore, they counted all
participants in the accident who legally drunk, even if they were not the
drivers. There’s no factual way it is proven that the vehicle fatalities due to
drivers being intoxicated has been decreasing because of the current drinking
age. Supporters of lowering the drinking age can claim that the use of DUI ads
and videos has scared drivers into obeying the law of drinking and driving.
Using the examples previously shown,
lowering the drinking age in America is an idealistic change that needs to be
made. If the drinking age were eighteen, young teens would not experiment with
alcohol in unsafe environments, binge drinking amongst youth will reduce, and
less college students will find pleasure in drinking because it is legal. As McCardell
says in his interview, it is obvious that prohibition on youth is ineffective. Some citizens in today’s society believe that lowering
the drinking age would cause nothing more than negative effects. Regardless of
age, alcohol is only a problem if the user does not drink responsibly.
Works Cited
Daniloff,
Caleb. "Drinking: 18 vs. 21." BU Today. Boston University, 21
Oct. 2010. Web. 10 Nov. 2013.
Engs,
Ruth C. "Why Drinking Age Should Be Lowered: Dr. Ruth Engs." Why
Drinking Age Should Be Lowered:
Dr. Ruth Engs. Ruth C. Engs, n.d. Web. 11 Nov. 2013.
Hanson,
David J. "Effective Alcohol Education: What Works with Underage
Youths." Alcohol: Problems and
Solutions. David J. Hanson, n.d. Web. 10 Nov. 2013.
Johnson,
Alex. "Debate on Lower Drinking Age Bubbling up." Nbcnews.com.
NBC News, 14 Aug. 2007. Web. 10 Dec.
2013.
Shields,
Wade. "Lowering Drinking Age Can Help Promote Safer Habits." Arizona
Daily Wildcat. University of
Arizona, 03 Sept. 2013. Web. 10 Dec. 2013.
Stromberg,
Drew. "Lowering the Drinking Age." Students for Sensible Drug
Policy. Students for Sensible Drug
Policy, n.d. Web. 09 Nov. 2013.
"The
Debate On Lowering The Drinking Age." CBSNews. Ed. CBS News. CBS
Interactive, 19 Feb. 2009. Web. 08
Dec. 2013.
No comments:
Post a Comment