Ryan
Santana
Ms.
Matyakubova
English
110, Section F
5
November 2013
Journal
Entry #9
Immigration
in America is an ongoing, controversial topic, which may or may not pose a
threat to our nation. The amount of reported illegal immigrants over the past years
has sky rocketed, and some citizens feel that this impacts the nation in a
negative way. Others feel that illegal and legal immigrants help benefit the
country in a positive way. Each immigrant, whether legal or illegal, has a
story or reason why they chose to migrate to the United States. Certain immigrants
travel to America in the hopes of pursuing a better job, to live a better
lifestyle. Other immigrants want their child or children to be raised in a
nation that represents freedom and opportunity. The choice to migrate made by
these immigrants does not only change the immigrant’s life, but it also affects
America as a whole.
The
idea of illegal and legal immigration being beneficial to America is strongly
reinforced by its supporters. Business owners like to hire illegal immigrants
because they do more hard labor for less money. The business owner also does
not have to worry about getting reported for labor law infractions being that
the worker should not be living in the United States in the first place. Pro
immigration enthusiasts also claim that illegal and legal immigrants take the
jobs that American citizens do not want but needs to be done. For business
owners who require cheap labor, illegal immigrants are welcomed with open arms.
As Richard Rayner states in his article “Illegal
Immigration Does Not Threaten America,” if there is a high requirement for
employment in a business, workers need to be willing to work for very little
pay. People that are for immigration also consider children who
are born in the United States to automatically be citizens even if their
parents are illegals. Thee reasoning behind pro immigration is not completely
supported by all citizens of America.
After
reading “America Must Take Stronger Measures to Halt Illegal Immigration”
by Michael Scott, I was exposed to a real life citizen whose life has been
affected by immigration. Because immigrants are on the run and risk the chance
of being deported, they may commit crimes on the way to their destination.
These crimes may include: stealing produce from farms, tearing down fences that
are in the way, and even leaving filth on private property (diapers, feces,
garbage). Once settled in the states, these immigrants cost American taxpayers
a run for their money. Illegal immigrant births costs $352 million. Welfare
costs for illegal immigrant children is $552 million. It costs $557 million to
incarcerate illegals, and $60 million in various health care costs. Scott
believes that the government is not doing as much as it should be when it comes
to immigration laws, resulting in a mass of illegal immigration. He encourages
tighter border implementation, deporting illegal immigrants who have already
found a way to America, and closing down the businesses of employers who hire illegals.
The main argument pro immigration
supporters pose is immigrants taking the necessary jobs that us citizens do not
want, but need in order to keep the economy and society stable. Citizens who do
not support pro immigration claim that with the costs of illegal immigrants and
its impact on our economy, they do more harm than help. I personally believe
that the article against illegal immigration has more supportive data because
of the costs, which convinces me to be a supporter of stricter actions made by
the Immigration and Naturalization Service.
No comments:
Post a Comment